CVE and CVSS: Vulnerability Assessment & Severity Ratings

Lahav Ezer, Product Manager

October 7, 2024

Protecting an organization's digital assets requires effective identifying, tracking, and managing vulnerabilities in today's ever-evolving cybersecurity landscape. Two fundamental components in this process are the Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) system and the Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS). While both play pivotal roles in vulnerability management, understanding their differences, how they complement each other, and their limitations is essential for a robust cybersecurity strategy.

What is CVE?

The Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) system is a standardized framework established in 1999 by MITRE to catalog publicly known cybersecurity vulnerabilities. Each CVE entry is assigned a unique identifier, such as CVE-2024-23750, which facilitates clear and consistent communication among cybersecurity professionals, organizations, and researchers.

Purpose and Functionality

The primary goal of the CVE system is to provide a common reference point for discussing and managing security vulnerabilities. By maintaining a centralized list, CVE enables organizations to monitor and respond to security threats more effectively. Key functionalities include:

Standardization: CVE standardizes the identification of vulnerabilities, allowing consistent references across different databases and tools.
Information Sharing: CVEs disseminate information about security threats to the broader community, ensuring all stakeholders are informed and can take appropriate action.
Patch Management: Organizations use CVE entries to track vulnerabilities related to their software and hardware, enabling timely patch management and remediation strategies.

Adoption and Impact

CVE’s significance is underscored by its widespread adoption and its extensive database, which includes over 240,830 records as of July 2024. Endorsed by key entities such as the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and the U.S. Defense Information Systems Agency, CVE has solidified its role as a critical resource in vulnerability management.

‍

Understanding CVSS

The Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) complements the CVE system by providing a standardized method for assessing the severity of vulnerabilities. CVSS assigns a numerical score ranging from 0.0 to 10.0, with higher scores indicating more severe security issues.

Scoring Mechanism

CVSS scores are calculated based on three primary metric groups:

Base Metrics: Reflect the inherent characteristics of a vulnerability that do not change over time or across environments. These include factors like Attack Vector (AV), Attack Complexity (AC), Privileges Required (PR), User Interaction (UI), Scope (S), and the impact on Confidentiality (C), Integrity (I), and Availability (A).
Temporal Metrics: Account for factors that may evolve, such as the availability of exploit code (E), remediation level (RL), and report confidence (RC).
Environmental Metrics: Allow organizations to tailor the CVSS scores based on their specific environments and risk tolerance. These consider the importance of confidentiality, integrity, and availability to the organization (CR, IR, AR) and any modified base metrics.

Recent Updates

The latest version, CVSSv4.0, released in November 2023, introduces refined metrics and improved scoring clarity. This version emphasizes that CVSS should not be solely relied upon for vulnerability prioritization but should serve as vital input in a broader decision-making process regarding risk management and remediation.

CVE vs. CVSS Scores

While CVE and CVSS are closely related, they serve distinct purposes in vulnerability management.

Aspect	CVE	CVSS
Definition	A standardized identifier for a publicly known vulnerability	A numerical score assessing the severity of a vulnerability
Purpose	To provide a common reference for discussing vulnerabilities	To prioritize vulnerabilities based on their severity
Scope	Catalogs vulnerabilities	Evaluate the impact and exploitability of vulnerabilities
Use Case	Identifying and tracking specific vulnerabilities	Prioritizing remediation efforts based on severity scores
Maintenance	Managed by MITRE and CVE Numbering Authorities	Managed by the CVSS community with regular updates

How They Work Together

CVE provides the identifier and description for each vulnerability, while CVSS assigns a severity score to help organizations prioritize which vulnerabilities to address first. Together, they offer a comprehensive framework for managing and mitigating security risks.

How to Map CVE Scores to CVSS

Mapping CVE entries to CVSS scores involves understanding both systems and utilizing them effectively in your vulnerability management process.

Step-by-Step Guide to Calculating CVSS Scores

Identify the CVE Entry: Start with the unique identifier and detailed description of the vulnerability.
Assess Base Metrics: Evaluate the inherent characteristics of the vulnerability, including attack vector, complexity, privileges required, user interaction, scope, and impact on confidentiality, integrity, and availability.
Evaluate Temporal Metrics: Consider factors that may change over time, such as the availability of exploit code, remediation level, and report confidence.
Adjust for Environmental Metrics: Tailor the score based on your organization’s specific context, including the importance of affected assets and existing security controls.
Calculate the Score: Use the CVSS calculator provided by NIST or other official tools to input the metrics and obtain the final CVSS score.

CVSS Score Ranges and Their Implications

CVSS Score Range	Severity	Implications
0	None	No impact. Vulnerability does not affect confidentiality, integrity, or availability.
0.1 - 3.9	Low	Limited impact. Requires minimal effort to exploit and may have minor effects.
4.0 - 6.9	Medium	Moderate impact. Exploitation requires some effort and affects one or more security properties.
7.0 - 8.9	High	Significant impact. Exploitation is feasible and affects multiple security properties.
9.0 - 10.0	Critical	Severe impact. Exploitation is highly feasible and affects all security properties.

Limitations of CVE and CVSS Scores

Despite their widespread use, CVE and CVSS have inherent limitations that can impact their effectiveness in vulnerability management.

Inconsistency and Inaccuracy

CVE scores can sometimes be inconsistent due to varying interpretations by vendors and analysts. Misinterpretations or misconfigurations in scoring metrics can lead to inaccurate severity ratings, complicating prioritization.

Lack of Contextual Information

CVE entries provide limited contextual information about how a vulnerability affects a specific environment. CVSS scores, while helpful, do not account for the unique configurations and mitigations present in an organization, potentially leading to misprioritization.

Overwhelming Volume

With over 240,830 CVE records as of July 2024, organizations can struggle to manage and prioritize vulnerabilities effectively. The sheer volume can lead to resource strain and oversight of critical vulnerabilities amidst numerous high-severity alerts.

Timeliness of Vulnerability Disclosures

Some CVEs are reserved until fixes are available, delaying crucial information from reaching organizations in need of remediation guidance. This delay can leave systems vulnerable to exploitation during the interim period.

Dependence on Accurate Data

The accuracy of CVSS scores relies heavily on the quality of input data. Inaccurate or incomplete data can distort the perceived severity of vulnerabilities, leading to ineffective risk management.

FAQ

What is the difference between CVE and CVSS?

CVE (Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures) is a system that provides standardized identifiers for publicly known cybersecurity vulnerabilities. CVSS (Common Vulnerability Scoring System) assigns numerical scores to these vulnerabilities to assess their severity. While CVE focuses on identification, CVSS focuses on prioritization based on severity.

Where can I find CVE and CVSS scores?

CVE entries and their corresponding CVSS scores can be found in databases such as the National Vulnerability Database (NVD) and MITRE’s CVE List. These databases provide detailed information and scoring metrics for each vulnerability.

What are some examples of use cases for CVE and CVSS scores?

Prioritizing Remediation Efforts: Organizations use CVSS scores to focus on the most critical vulnerabilities first.
Regulatory Compliance: CVE and CVSS help organizations meet security standards and regulatory requirements by providing a standardized vulnerability management framework.
Security Reporting: CVE and CVSS scores are used in security reports to communicate the severity and impact of vulnerabilities to stakeholders.

‍

How Opus’s vulnerability assessment builds on CVE and CVSS scoring

Opus Security’s vulnerability assessment builds on CVE (Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures) and CVSS (Common Vulnerability Scoring System) scoring by enhancing these foundational metrics with advanced, AI-powered analysis, real-time intelligence, and business context. Here's how Opus improves upon the traditional use of CVE and CVSS:

1. Unified Vulnerability Management

CVE and CVSS provide a standardized method of identifying and scoring vulnerabilities, but they often need more full context for effective prioritization. Opus leverages CVE data to ensure comprehensive vulnerability coverage across the entire IT infrastructure. The CVSS Base Score, widely used for assessing the severity of vulnerabilities, serves as the foundation in Opus's multi-layer prioritization framework.

2. AI-Enhanced Intelligence

While CVSS offers static severity ratings, it doesn't account for dynamic risk factors like exploitability or active threat campaigns. Opus builds on this by using AI-based vulnerability intelligence to assess real-time factors such as exploit maturity, threat actor activities, and discussions in hacker forums. This enables Opus to flag vulnerabilities that may be more likely to be exploited in the wild.

3. Contextual Analysis

One of the limitations of CVE and CVSS is that they do not consider the specific business environment or context in which the vulnerabilities exist. Opus adds contextual impact to vulnerability assessments by analyzing how vulnerabilities affect critical business functions, services, and systems. By evaluating factors such as data sensitivity, compliance requirements, and operational importance, Opus provides a more tailored and accurate risk assessment.

4. Risk Customization and Prioritization

Opus allows organizations to customize risk scoring based on their unique business needs, regulatory requirements, and risk appetite. This customization includes adjusting the weight given to specific vulnerabilities, allowing organizations to prioritize the greatest threat to their critical infrastructure and compliance obligations.

5. Multi-Layer Prioritization Framework

Opus’s multi-layered prioritization framework takes CVE and CVSS scoring a step further by incorporating additional layers of intelligence and contextual data. This ensures that vulnerabilities are not only ranked based on their CVSS score but also on factors like business criticality, environmental context, and actual exploitability.

‍

Summary

CVE and CVSS are indispensable tools in the cybersecurity arsenal. They enable organizations to systematically identify, assess, and prioritize vulnerabilities. CVE provides a standardized identification system, while CVSS offers a numerical method to gauge the severity of these vulnerabilities. Together, they facilitate effective vulnerability management and risk mitigation.

However, the dynamic nature of cyber threats and the limitations inherent in CVE and CVSS systems necessitate a more robust approach to vulnerability assessment. Traditional methods can be resource-intensive and may struggle to keep pace with the rapidly evolving threat landscape. This is where advanced security remediation platforms like Opus Security come into play, offering automated, comprehensive solutions that build upon the foundational frameworks of CVE and CVSS. Integrating these tools into your cybersecurity strategy can achieve a more resilient and efficient defense against emerging threats.

‍